i have a hyde, and have no problems with it other than mud, which is easily remedied with foam or wire mesh. and i think it does fine for the pipe. it is good for protecting your cases, but doesnt prevent dents to your frame. id weighs next to nothing, comes off and on easy once your familiar, and is very reasonable on cost. i dont like the front bracket, as it didnt fit my frame(i had to bend it to shape, no big deal) and ive heard that the threads that the mounting bolts break off. im planing to make a different front bracket when i get time, but this one works for now. i like mine, also, the carbon and plastic ones absorb noise, so they are quieter. although i would imagine that foam under a metal one would do the same.