Thanks for the feedback. I too have Gearne SG 10s, and I do like them, but the deal for the Scotts had me considering them.
Jeff, believe it or not, I had a set of the plastic Scott boots when I rode an XR 75, they were a hand me down, and I was just happy to be riding, it was my dad who made me wear boots and a helmet. I was happy to oblige, just get me on that bike! I honestly don't remember anything bad or good about those boots. I was hoping that after lo these many moons, they would have come up with a good design. I did read a couple of those reviews, and honestly the only thing that sticks out for me is that one review commented that they breath well, and hence leak. That would not work for me.